Note: revised and appended on 8/10/23 from an older article

The quaint town of Lyndon, Vermont is home to many historic buildings, one of which is the Cahoon Farm. This stately Georgian home was built between 1798 and 1802 by the Cahoon family, originally from Providence, Rhode Island. The Cahoon Farm home is said to be the oldest two-story residence in Lyndon and remains a landmark of the town's early history.

Table of Contents hide

1 The Vermont Northeast Kingdom and it's Legends of Haunting and Eerie Ghost Stories

1.1 Cahoon Farm's Ghostly Reputation

1.1.1 My children swear I didn’t tell them about the ghosts before we settled into what I’ve come to learn is one of Lyndon’s most famous haunted houses.

1.1.2 It felt like I’d come home. I hadn’t really.

1.2 Ghosts still visit Cahoon Farm

1.2.1 I’d not said anything to my friend or her daughter about the woman in black.

1.2.2 Yet Another Cahoon Farm Ghost Story

1.2.3 A funeral alcove within the house

1.2.4 The Playful Poltergeist

The Vermont Northeast Kingdom and it's Legends of Haunting and Eerie Ghost Stories

According to local legend, the spirit of Daniel Cahoon, who died in 1811 after being charged by a bull, still resides within the home's antique walls. Generations of Cahoons inhabited the home, also known as the Hoffman House, for over two centuries until 1999. That year, Denise Brown relocated from Connecticut and became the latest owner.

Cahoon Farm's Ghostly Reputation

Upon moving in, Brown was informed of the home's ghostly reputation. Having recently lost her husband tragically, Brown found the idea of a benevolent spirit comforting. In the past twelve years, she has experienced some unexplained occurrences, like heavy footsteps on the stairs at night. During one frightening incident, Brown pleaded for the noises to cease and they promptly did.

Other guests have reported paranormal encounters as well. Some claimed to see a ghostly woman in period dress or a specter holding his head in despair. There are also stories of blankets being stripped away, glasses tinkling downstairs, and music playing spontaneously. The Cahoon and Hoffman families were pillars of early Lyndon, holding various civic positions. Their festive gatherings in the home's large upper floor likely explain the residual echoes of merriment.

Though most experiences in the house have been harmless, some visitors felt an inexplicable unease. Brown herself once saw the apparition of a widow, perhaps a former resident, after renovating her kitchen. As a young widow, Brown felt a kinship with this spiritual sister rather than fear.

The Cahoon Farm's supernatural tales add character to an already historic home. Perhaps the spirits dwelling within remain out of fondness for the stately farmhouse they once called home or to reassure newcomers like Brown. Either way, the ghosts of Cahoon Farm demonstrate that the bonds of home and family can truly last an eternity.

The following is from and article by Denise Brown, courtesy of Scott Wheeler

My children swear I didn’t tell them about the ghosts before we settled into what I’ve come to learn is one of Lyndon’s most famous haunted houses.

Maybe that’s true. Their father had died, and I was eager to move from Connecticut, and didn’t feel that a few spirits lingering about should deter us. But in truth, I didn’t put much stock into the stories the realtor told me anyway.

The old house had stood empty for several years. The shutters, those that remained, were broken and askew; the shrubs overgrown; one door was boarded up against the weather. Dark stains on the ceilings signaled the roof needed serious repair. The heat and electricity were off, and the air that hung in the dusty rooms was as bitter cold as that outside. But I fell in love with Cahoon Farm moments after I walked inside.

It felt like I’d come home. I hadn’t really.

Cahoon Farm, built in 1798, had stayed in the Cahoon-Hoffman family for two centuries. You could say it still has, given its historical importance and our occasional nighttime visitors. Over our five years here, I have come to think that at best we’re sharing the property. But I think that’s true for anyone who purchases and attempts to preserve a historic home. We become caretakers of the past.

The previous owner, Horty Hoffman, was an historian herself, and in the early seventies had lovingly and authentically papered and appointed the old homestead, and conducted numerous house tours and field trips for students from the graded school. I don’t try to keep pace with Mrs. Hoffman’s efforts, but it has been a pleasure now and then to open our home to visitors, reporters, and students. And while many are intrigued by the ornate woodwork in the formal parlor, the wide pine planks in the hall, or the spacious symmetry of the rooms, the first thing almost everyone asks is, “Have you seen any ghosts?” Quite a few people have professed to have seen ghosts over the centuries.

Ghosts still visit Cahoon Farm

We should begin at the beginning, with the story of Daniel Cahoon, Sr., who in September of 1811, was gored to death while rescuing a child from a bull. Ol’ Dan’l was laid out in an upstairs bedroom known as the Green Room, and it’s his ghost who is said to be heard tromping up the stairs some evenings. And what he’s looking for is also the stuff of folklore—a wine cellar supposedly boarded up by his grieving widow, who was convinced it was a potent drink that brought about her husband’s demise. People have been searching for that cellar ever since. And so has Dan’l, according to legend.

In other stories, overnight visitors have been awakened by ghosts: one supposedly played a bit of tug of war with one guest’s blankets, and another held his head in his hands and mourned the drowning of his young son. Clayton Homman, Dan’l’s descendant who rarely talked about ghosts, is said to have seen one himself by his bedside—a young woman in old-fashioned dress. Some have heard music playing and glasses tinkling in the parlor that once held the first piano in Lyndon. A young couple dressed for a wedding—the woman in white, a man in top hat and black jacket—showed up one morning in that upstairs Green Room, which at one time could be expanded into an area fit for ceremonies and balls by lifting up a retractable wall.

I suppose skeptics and psychologists could have a field day explaining away such sightings as the products of over-stimulated imagination or worse. And I don’t want to give the impression that these sorts of things happened regularly in this old house. In our five years, we’ve experienced relatively few mysterious happenings: an electric fan that turned itself on several times, for example, sudden volume changes of the television set, or doors that open and shut by themselves. Things that go bump in the night. All manner of occurrences that could be explained away as power surges, or the creaks and groans that accompany the settling of an old house.

But I have one story to tell. See what you think of this. Shortly after I moved into the house, I decided to have the kitchen counter top replaced. The morning this work was completed, I was standing at the sink, running a dishtowel over the new counter, happy with the job. And I saw a figure float by the kitchen door. She was a bit taller than I, all draped in what seemed to be black lace. And my immediate thought was, “There’s the widow of the house checking on the new widow of the house.” I stepped into the hallway, but she was gone.

A few weeks later, a good friend came to visit. Late in the evening, her daughter went downstairs to get a glass of water from the kitchen, and in roughly the same area of the hall, she saw a woman standing before her. The following morning, she sketched her for me, describing the very figure I had seen: a woman of the same height, the same lace covering head and hands.

I’d not said anything to my friend or her daughter about the woman in black.

A few years later, I decided to replace the worn linoleum in the kitchen. And the morning that job was completed the lady returned. Only this time I saw her floating by the doorway all in white radiant. Perhaps at peace.

Why would a ghost come to visit my kitchen? The history of Cahoon Farm offers an explanation. At one time, what is now the kitchen was divided, and inside of it was a small, sealed-off room. In that room, the family kept a patient—perhaps someone chronically ill, perhaps someone insane. It’s uncertain. But in that tiny cell, the family member was cared for and kept safe.

It seems to me that the lady ghost must have had a deep devotion to the loved one in that room. She returns whenever something pulls her energy back, some change she needs to investigate, or the appearance of a visitor of whom she is unsure.

“Weren’t you afraid?” I’ve been asked, upon telling the story. Of course I wasn’t. Not at all. And neither was my friend’s daughter. We all had someone watching over us with such tenderness and concern, while we are alive to appreciate it.

Yet Another Cahoon Farm Ghost Story

Madeline Hoffman Hall and her older sister grew up with the ghost of Daniel Cahoon, a distant ancestor. Apparently, he had a habit of stalking the halls of the historic homestead on East Lyndon Road.

The Georgian style home was finished around 1798 by Daniel Cahoon Jr, Daniel Cahoon's son, who was one of the town's settlers. Daniel Jr. died of tuberculosis at the young age of 26, and his father moved into the house.

A funeral alcove within the house

Madeline's family lived in the home years later. She was the skeptic of the family and said that she never experienced any type of ghostly activity. Her bedroom was on the second floor and was the room where Daniel and other members of the family were “laid out” for funeral services after they passed away. Some in the family refer to the area as the “haunted chamber”. Although Madeline claims that she herself never experienced anything unusual, others will not sleep there.

Two of her children claimed a haunting experience when the family occupied the house in the 1960's. They reported uneasy feelings within the second floor area and would not sleep there. Madeline's sister, however, was an enthusiastic believer in ghosts and loved to share stories.

Most of the stories consisted of heavy footsteps up and down the stairs, while everyone was fast asleep. Kit Hoffman, Daniel's grandson 3 generations down, patiently tolerated the ghostly activities of his ancestor. His wife, however, was a bit frightened when on a sub-zero morning, she awoke to the sound of a slamming front door, accompanied by door slams and heavy footsteps walking about the hallways. When confronted by his frightened wife, Kit said nonchalantly, “That's just Dan'l, our family ghost”.

The Playful Poltergeist

Apparently, Daniel was quite the playful poltergeist. A ghost with a sense of humor! There was the story of a woman who stayed at the house one night, brushing her hair when suddenly at the foot of the bed sunk as if an unseen person sat down. Another friend of the family, stayed the night and awoke in the middle of the night as something pulled the blankets away from her shoulders. This brought on a gentle tug of war between the guest and the ghost.

Another unusual event occurred when a friend was visiting and awoke to the sound of music playing. It seemed like 18th century music and eventually became louder. Nearby, she could hear gentle whispering voices, a woman's laughter and the distinct sound of glassware and silverware being moved about. Oddly enough the smell of snuff permeated the room. Perhaps ghostly memories being relived from days long past when dances and parties were held at the house?

As for Daniel himself, he was gored to death by a bull in 1811 at age 74, passing through the barnyard, (apparently while on a search for a wine cellar or more likely a still). His widow blamed his death on frequent visits to the “wine cellar” and had it boarded up. Nobody ever did find the actual location of the wine cellar after that.

From an article in Virginia Campbell Down's book, Mansions & Meadows, a book published in 1991 by the Lyndon Historical SocietySave

Bestseller No. 1